How the dots are worked out
A book's dot uses every line that book posted for the player: yardage, receptions, passing touchdowns and its anytime-touchdown price, turned into expected touchdowns. Where a book posted no line for a stat, the consensus (the median across books) stands in, so a dot moves only on what that book actually priced.
The hollow dot is Kalshi, a prediction market rather than a sportsbook. The thin mark is the consensus, and every row uses the same scale, so a wide row really is a wider disagreement. Only players priced by at least three sources, in games that have not kicked off, are listed.
Lines from DraftKings, FanDuel, BetMGM, Caesars, Bovada, BetRivers, BetOnline, Fanatics and Kalshi.